Skip to content

What is dispute management in accounts receivable? Process and example

Accounts receivable, billing and collections

Definition

Dispute management is the process of logging, investigating, and resolving customer objections to invoices, such as wrong prices, short shipments, or damaged goods. The undisputed part should be paid on time; the disputed part is either credited with a credit memo or confirmed and collected.

Scope
Invoice objections
Undisputed part
Pay on time
Valid dispute
Credit memo
Key metric
Days to resolve

What causes invoice disputes?

Most invoice disputes come from a mismatch between the invoice and what the customer ordered, received, or agreed.

Reason codeExampleUsual owner
PricingInvoice price differs from the contract or quoteSales or pricing
QuantityFewer units received than billedWarehouse or logistics
Damaged goodsGoods arrived broken or spoiledQuality or logistics
Missing PO or paperworkCustomer can't match the invoice to a purchase orderBilling
Promotions and rebatesAgreed discount not appliedSales
Duplicate billingSame delivery invoiced twiceBilling

Coding every dispute by reason shows which team causes the most, so you fix the cause, not just the invoice.

How does the dispute management process work?

The dispute management process logs the dispute, pauses reminders on the disputed amount, finds the facts, and ends with a credit memo or confirmation.

  1. Log: Record the invoice, amount, reason code, and date raised
  2. Split: Ask the customer to pay the undisputed part now
  3. Pause: Stop dunning on the disputed amount only
  4. Investigate: Compare the invoice with the contract, purchase order, and proof of delivery
  5. Decide: A named approver issues a credit memo for the valid part
  6. Close: Tell the customer the outcome and collect what's still owed

Dispute management example

Example: Keystone Office Supply invoices Riverbend Schools $30,000 (INV-7720) on Monday, August 31, 2026, on net 30 terms. On Friday, September 18, Riverbend disputes $4,000: it says it was billed list price instead of its contract price. All amounts are illustrative.

  • Monday, September 28: The contract shows a $2,500 overcharge; Keystone issues a credit memo for $2,500. The other $1,500 was a rush delivery fee the contract allows
  • Wednesday, September 30: Riverbend pays the undisputed $26,000 on the due date
  • Friday, October 16: Riverbend pays the remaining $1,500
DateAccountDebitCredit
Sep 28, 2026Sales returns and allowances2,500
Accounts receivable, Riverbend Schools2,500
Sep 30, 2026Cash26,000
Accounts receivable, Riverbend Schools26,000
Oct 16, 2026Cash1,500
Accounts receivable, Riverbend Schools1,500
Total30,00030,000
INV-7720Amount
Invoice, August 31$30,000
Less: credit memo, September 28(2,500)
Less: payment of undisputed amount, September 30(26,000)
Less: payment, October 16(1,500)
Balance$0

The dispute took 10 days to resolve (September 18 to September 28), so the credit memo already reduces September revenue. If a dispute is still open at period end, estimate the credit you expect to give and reduce revenue in that period; under ASC 606, expected price concessions are variable consideration, not a credit loss.

Dispute management KPIs

Dispute management is measured by how many disputes arise, how long they take, and how many turn out to be valid.

  • Average days to resolve: From date raised to decision
  • Disputed AR: Open disputed amounts as a share of total AR
  • Valid dispute rate: Share of disputes that end in a credit memo
  • Disputes by reason code: Which cause, and which team, is growing

What is dispute management confused with?

Dispute management is most often confused with deductions management, where the customer has already short-paid, and with card chargebacks.

TermWhat it isHow it differs from dispute management
DeductionsAmounts a customer subtracts from a payment for claims such as promotions, shortages, or damagesThe customer has already taken the money; disputes may come before payment
Short paymentCustomer payment that is less than the invoiced amount, often because of a deduction, dispute, or billing disagreementA result of an unresolved or self-resolved dispute
ChargebackA reversal of a card payment that the cardholder's bank initiates after the customer disputes the chargeRuns through the card network's rules, not your own process
Credit memo (credit note)Document that reduces the amount a customer owes, issued for returns, pricing errors, or allowancesThe usual outcome of a valid dispute

Dispute management at month end

At month end, open disputes affect revenue and the allowance, as part of the month-end close.

  1. List open disputes: Amount, age, and reason for each
  2. Estimate credits: Reduce revenue for credits you expect to give
  3. Separate credit risk: Customers who dispute to delay payment belong in the allowance review
  4. Tie out: Agree the AR aging, including disputed items, to the control account

Our Close Agent ties the AR subledger to the general ledger at close and prepares the entry, and nothing posts until a named approver signs off.

Common dispute management mistakes

The most common dispute management mistakes let one disputed line hold up the whole invoice.

  • Holding the whole invoice: Collect the undisputed part on time
  • Dunning the disputed amount: It annoys the customer and changes nothing
  • Booking valid disputes as bad debt: A pricing error reduces revenue; it isn't a credit loss
  • No reason codes: The same error repeats next month
  • Credits without approval: Every credit memo needs a named approver